Growing feud with Amazon: new devices have mysteriously disappeared

Gregory FrenchDec 10, 20173 8466 votes +4 rating

Three months ago, YouTube pulled its programming from Amazon’s Echo Show device – the first skirmish in what is apparently an ongoing war. Shortly after, Amazon stopped selling the Nest E Thermostat, Nest’s Camera IQ, and the Nest Secure alarm system. Two weeks ago, Amazon got YouTube back on the Echo Show by simply directing users to the web version, a workaround that left a lot to be desired. But even that version won’t be available after today.

© Article’s author: Ben Popper.
© Source: The Verge

New Nest devices have mysteriously disappeared from Amazon

User’s reaction in social media:

It actually has always been using Bing for a while. When it can’t answer a question, it shows you Bing results in the app. This is why Google is so afraid of the Echo. The Echo is easier to use than Google in someone’s house. Instead of opening a device and Googling something, they are afraid people are going to start just asking Alexa. Part of the reason Google is unhappy here is because they were desperately attempting to create a Google Home with a screen to compete with the Echo Show in time for the holidays. When it became apparent they can’t do it in time for a 2017 release, they made up this policy out of spite. There is spite both ways of course but in this specific instance they are upset over the potential market loss. It’s the first time they see a threat in any capacity to their search business.

In a statement this afternoon, a YouTube spokesperson announced that the company was withdrawing support for its service on both the Echo Show and, more importantly, Amazon’s Fire TV:

“​We’ve been trying to reach agreement with Amazon to give consumers access to each other’s products and services. But Amazon doesn’t carry Google products like Chromecast and Google Home, doesn’t make Prime Video available for Google Cast users, and last month stopped selling some of Nest’s latest products. Given this lack of reciprocity, we are no longer supporting YouTube on Echo Show and FireTV. We hope we can reach an agreement to resolve these issues soon.”

User’s reaction in social media:

Amazon is a store. Stores pick what they want to sell. Especially for a physical product that has associated storage and handling costs. Walmart or BestBuy could choose to stop selling Google devices and be no different. the Google Store doesn’t sell anything but Google hardware. Stores get to pick what they sell. Youtube is not a store, it is a service that Google is choosing to block a valid customer of that complies with their terms of use and api requirements. At this point they’re specifically blocking a certain web browser from loading the site. How would you feel if Google blocked Firefox, or Hulu or Netflix blocked Chrome?

YouTube will be pulled from the Echo Show today. Customers who own an Fire TV will start seeing a notification today warning them that the service will be unavailable as of January 1st, 2018. Perhaps Google is hoping that the threat of losing YouTube on its main streaming device will force Amazon to negotiate a truce both sides can live with before the new year.

User’s reaction in social media:

Amazon is not just a store. They are a manufacturer of tech products, a media content giant, and they are unfairly leveraging their ownership of the biggest store in the world to legally eliminate competition. Google has every right to fight back and demand reciprocity! The fact that this goes against Google’s core culture just shows how underhanded and uncompetitive Amazon’s practices have been in a long time. Considering what Amazon does when you ask Alexa, Google should direct all search requests for Amazon branded products to their closest competition.

There was a time when Amazon offered their app store within the Amazon shopping app. An entire app store within the guise of a shopping app. One, where 99.9% of the apps were duplicates of ones in the Play Store. Is anyone surprised that app got kicked? It was allowed back in once the Amazon app store functionality was removed.

For bonus points, try asking Alexa to order you a Chromecast and see how she responds. I was offered a Fire TV stick, then a Roku, before she ran out of options.

Total: 2 comments
Please note! In order to quote the entire comment - click “Quote” without selecting anything. To quote a part of the comment - first select it, then click “Quote”.
  1. Trevory Mogger
    1
    6
    2017-12-10, 12:36PM
    You're reading a little too far into it and making too much of something that's not really the case. Google doesn't want to not be the best search engine but you have to understand that in no way is the number of searches on Amazon devices which default to Bing anywhere near putting pressure on Google's search business or likely to anytime soon.

    Google is not afraid of the Echo anymore than they're afraid of the Kindle Fire or Fire sticks. I'm sure they would love to have an equivalent competing product but the reason for that is they get to control the system.

    They pulled YouTube originally because Amazon built it themselves to circumvent the features Google put in place to drive revenue - you know, literally every part of YouTube that goes alongside the video content. Amazon doesn't want to work with Google to build the app appropriately and Google is pulling the plug because it's basically a pirate broadcast and allowing Amazon to do it encourages others to try similar in the future.

    In that situation, Google gets blamed for any features that don't work properly or which don't produce revenue the way they should (ads, selling movies, etc.). YouTube is a massive product and anything that takes control away from Google whittles away at it even if it facially seems pro-consumer. The last thing Google wants is for YouTube to suddenly become a public utility or become generic because they're expected to provide everyone access to the videos however they want to jack into the feed.
    +6
  2. Gregory French
    3
    6
    Author: Gregory FrenchJournalist
    2017-12-10, 12:19PM
    Hmmm... Streaming Amazon Prime on Chrome on my Pixel phone right now. So no Amazon is not blocking that. Also, Amazon doesn't block Chromecast. You can't block something that is not there. Google can't write their code into the Amazon video app. Thats like saying Microsoft is blocking Gmail on their Windows 10 store.
    -5
Write a review
Information
To add a comment to this publication, you need to register or Log In.
Share a link with your friends:
With “Growing feud with Amazon: new devices have mysteriously disappeared” also read
GadgetsBest cutting-edge products: the 10 most popular Gadgets of 2017
3 941 4
Technology companies like Microsoft, Samsung, Apple are constantly finding new ways to improve their cutting-edge products. There are several big changes in 2017.
MobileShopping: iPhone X, Pixel 2 or Galaxy S8 - how each phone differs from one another
3 897 1 5
iOS or Android? If you’re shopping for a new smartphone, there’s a good chance three options come to mind: Apple iPhone X, Samsung Galaxy S8, Google Pixel 2.
Technology13 Cool Tech Gifts you must have and don’t have to spend a fortune on them
3 455 2 4
We have some real deals for less than $50. If you’re a generous type and have a big family or lot of friends, the holidays can be a financially taxing time.
FinanceRetail renaissance: Big Shopping Trends in 2018 - the signs are promising
4 033 4 6
2017 was the year of the retail apocalypse. Tech transformation. Retail is a people business. Predictions: pot, politics and Bitcoin. New business models will emerge.
Even more publications
New articles announcement
In the air: Recent Comments
2018-01-17, 5:53AM
Double loft beds similar the black one available in various mattress sizes made to your choice of headroom, with a choice of sloping or..To get you inspired: 12 awesome ideas where to put a bed in a tiny room
2018-01-17, 5:48AM
Great Collection of space savers! With more and more tiny houses becoming popular, ideas such as these are great examples that could be..To get you inspired: 12 awesome ideas where to put a bed in a tiny room
2018-01-16, 12:04PM
The best of interior decoration I have ever seen, awesome creativity! Cool ideas, but some of these are totally removed from possibility if..To get you inspired: 12 awesome ideas where to put a bed in a tiny room
2018-01-16, 11:07AM
As a college student wrote, this post stood out. I always have the problem of too many things in too little of a space. If this post was..To get you inspired: 12 awesome ideas where to put a bed in a tiny room
2018-01-16, 5:51AM
In-home services, delivery, and consultations will pervade the market. Consumers no longer want to leave the house to buy commodities. So,..Retail renaissance: Big Shopping Trends in 2018 - the signs are promising
2018-01-16, 5:29AM
Healthy and environment-friendly lifestyles will be a focus for many consumers. Consumers will be increasingly mindful of their purchases...Retail renaissance: Big Shopping Trends in 2018 - the signs are promising
Popular Comments
2018-01-7, 1:22PM
Simple solutions: 1. You live off of handouts you can't vote. Let those who pay the bill decide. 2. Welfare because your a single..Welfare reform: 6 million open jobs - the challenge is to get people back to work
2017-12-23, 3:49PM
"It's time for the Jedi, and for Star Wars... to end." The Last Jedi is one giant cinematographic anticlimax. Each..“Star Wars” recovering? “The Last Jedi” has earned around $570m around the world
2017-12-10, 6:09PM
Amazon forked Android and made it into their own proprietary FireOS. They had Amazon Prime video locked up and only available on it for..Even for $30 and out of curiosity I can’t buy Home Mini smart speaker
2017-12-20, 10:03PM
Let's talk about the impact on federal debt. This bill appears to create a $2 trillion deficit over the next ten years. That is about..9 things about historic Tax Reform - Trump’s first big legislative win
2017-12-20, 6:07PM
This is never going to happen. Republicans are NOT going to cut, they will continue to explain that a growing economy will grow them out of..9 things about historic Tax Reform - Trump’s first big legislative win
2017-12-20, 1:05PM
Where to begin. This bill is far from perfect, but Obamacare is probably not a great comparison. The fundamental underpinnings of Obamacare..Final reform: U.S. Senate passed the biggest in history Tax Cut and Reform Bill
Most viewed in the past 24 hours
Most viewed in the month
Popular news topics
5G Apple beds Bitcoin breaking news broadband business news cryptocurrency device entertainment film finance furniture gadgets Google Google Home Mini holiday shopping home furniture home security iPhone iPhone battery iPhone slowdown latex mattress markets mattress media mobile movie review news older iPhones opinion politics reforms retail Samsung security shopping smart speaker smartphone Star Wars stocks T-Mobile tax laws tax reform taxes tech tech news technology The Last Jedi U.S. Senate
» » Growing feud with Amazon: new devices have mysteriously disappeared