“Star Wars” recovering? “The Last Jedi” has earned around $570m around the world

Chris MaccenroyDec 23, 20172 6691 vote +1 rating

With another over/under $34 million worldwide on Wednesday, “Star Wars Episode VIII: The Last Jedi” has now earned around $570 million around the world, including an approximate $280 million in North America. Barring a fluke, the film should end today with just under $300 million domestic and just over $600 million worldwide. How on Earth can the Star Wars franchise possibly recover from this monstrosity?

© Article’s author: Scott Mendelson.
© Source: Forbes

Star Wars The Last JediRian Johnson, who has been given a stand-alone Star Wars trilogy to oversee once the current one wraps up, crafted a film that has earned overwhelmingly positive reviews. Including a 93% “fresh” and 8.1/10 critic ranking on Rotten Tomatoes. It also has an 86% score on Metacritic and a 7.9/10 user rating on IMDb.com. Oh, and the film received an A from Cinemascore and a 90 from comScore. My god, what will Lucasfilm do now?

But wait, there is more terrible news. It may have to wait until Friday to pass $300 million domestic and/or the global gross of Justice League ($637m+). At a glance, the film may end the second weekend with only over/under $400 million domestic and over/under $800m worldwide heading into Christmas Day. With the next full week of holiday business offering a slew of newbie competitors, the $250m+ sci-fi actioner may have to wait until the end of the year to cross $1 billion global.

Some of comments on the IMDb:

Is it a parody? There are some well written and comprehensive reviews on here already so I won’t waste your time in the details. Essentially, the entire first half of The Last Jedi feels like a Star Wars parody. Instead of the odd moment of humour every now and again, every scene AND character is a comedian in TLJ. It’s a crap gag a minute. And some of the great work done The Force Awakens to re-energize the franchise was just completely undone.

You know that incredibly significant and poignant moment at the end of TFA as Rey hands the lightsabre to Luke? Just wait and see what happens next. I’ve rated it 4 stars because the second half of the film does pick up but by then the damage is done. TLJ is a huge misstep in the franchise.

My god, say it with me now… can this franchise be saved?

I’m sure that the folks who flooded the Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic user polls with negative reviews were real people and not robots or spam programs. But there is a rather high number of folks who apparently created an account specifically to offer a poor review of the newest Star Wars movie and then deleted the account. James Emanuel Shapiro did the hard work over at “Birth. Death. Movies” detailing that, of 100 random negative user reviews from Rotten Tomatoes, 94% of them either had no account or were first-time users. Of 100 random negative Metacritic user reviews, 72% of them were new users.

As James Emanuel Shapiro writes in his review: “The curious case of The Last Jedi and its Rotten Tomatoes audience score”:

Still, I randomly pulled 100 “poor reviews” (score of one or less) from both sites, and noted when they first started reviewing content and how many reviews they have contributed.

Rotten Tomatoes audience score

As you can see, there were a lot of respondents who signed up to review The Last Jedi and with Rotten Tomatoes, and a third of the respondents deleted their account or had their account deleted after registering. This suggests an effort was made to create a negative self-selecting bias because these new users chose to register with the site just to have their review counted in the overall Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic score for the title. There are some other issues with these polls – there’s no guarantee that the respondents actually watched the film and there’s also the ability for the same unique individuals to vote multiple times, and I could see in my data pull the same review pop up a few times or the same name pop up a few times. I also noticed, but could not include this data since, again, neither site collected demographic information, that an overwhelming majority of the respondents had male names. An educated guess would be 90% or more.

Maybe they review-bombed as some kind of anti-SJW conspiracy (take a look at the downvotes on YouTube for the Ocean’s 8 trailer) or skewed revenge from DC fans over Justice League. Or maybe the segment of online fans who didn’t like the movie flooded the opt-in polling and thus created the impression of poor word-of-mouth. But every other measurement thus far (the reviews, the initial box office, the audience polling from folks who absolutely saw the movie, etc.) would indicate that folks loved or at least somewhat enjoyed The Last Jedi.

Some of comments on the IMDb:

The Last Jedi is so bad on so many levels! I don’t know where to start with this utter abomination of a Star Wars movie. It’s like Rian & Disney took everything that J.J. Abrams wrote and threw it out the window. There is no explanation who Ray and Snoke are and who were the Knights of Ren, Snoke is even killed off in the middle of the movie in a ridiculous way. The way they changed Luke Skywalker as a character is is just sad. All the hype where lukes blue lightsaber came from in The Force awakens was for nothing. There was not even a proper lightsaber battle in the end.

And yet, despite this perfect storm of pretty good press and rock-solid box office, the overriding narrative right now is “What went wrong?” or “How Star Wars can be fixed!” That we are discussing the controversy, even whether the controversy is genuine, means we are letting these folks dictate the terms of the conversation. This is little different than having a singular climate change scientist or singular pro-gun purchase background checks politician debating a singular opponent on the other side and then acting as if both sides have equally strong levels of support.

Some of comments on the “Rotten Tomatoes”:

Each of these characters finds a surprising connection to others, derailing plans and sending each person on an unexpected journey. The way Johnson orchestrates all of this is remarkable because it’s both coherent and compelling.

Star Wars: The Last Jedi (2017). IMDb’s User Ratings. For now 186.938 IMDb users have given a weighted average vote of 7.7/10:

IMDb User RatingsWithout discounting audience members (and critics and writers) who genuinely didn’t like Star Wars: The Last Jedi, the user polling is a deviation from the narrative, not the backbone of the post-release narrative. Most folks thus far thought The Last Jedi was at least “fine”, just as they thought (for example) Spectre, Iron Man 3 or Star Trek into Darkness were “fine.” At worst, Star Wars is in a place similar to the James Bond franchise, whereby Spectre was hated by a number of folks and fans (raises hand) but still snagged $880 million worldwide and left the 007 series in a relatively healthy place.

Some of comments on the “Rotten Tomatoes”:

Its scattered pacing and tangled subplots doesn’t make The Last Jedi a failure, but neither is it a celebration – or more importantly, an elevation – of anything other than the legacies of the late Carrie Fisher, and justly revered Mark Hamill.

As always, the problems with the user polling from sites like Rotten Tomatoes or the up-vote/down-vote systems employed by YouTube are not the applications themselves, but how the media uncritically and unquestioningly takes those results as proverbial gospel or part of a wider truth without considering variables that might have skewed the results. Whether individually or en masse, the folks who hated Star Wars: The Last Jedi flooded the most visible opt-in polling site and single-handedly changed the conversation about a movie that otherwise was doing quite well. That’s not a huge deal, but it’s something to consider as so-called critical opinion becomes more democratized.

Some of comments on the IMDb:

So our resistant heroes continue their fight against the Second Empire. Not much really happens unless you consider killing off various characters significant. (Admiral Ackbar!) No real answers or explanations to any of Abrams ‘mystery box’ storytelling. Who’s Snoke? Dunno. Who’s Rey? Nobody. Long winded and filled with awkward humour (Luke milking a thing) and pointless adventures. (Finn’s trip to a space casino which ends up accomplishing exactly nothing) Filled with confusing story telling where characters turn bad (or good) and back again for no reason and people show up out of the blue with no explanation as to how they got there.

(How did Rey meet up with Chewie again?) Like Han in the last film Luke is really only in it to pass the torch and is just treated in an embarrassing manner. Strangely Leia survives and I’m expecting her to be written out in the opening crawl for the next one. These new movies are written in a TV variety style where characters and things show up for a round of applause and then go away. These new movies are more in the style of the Star Wars Holiday Special than the original movies. Frankly it’s just weird. The Harry Potter-esque final scene was the most Un-Star Wars scene ever...

The folks who pushed down the Star Wars Episode VIII: The Last Jedi scores didn’t necessarily game the system, but they did trick you and me by convincing us to look at the one shiny object that was different from all the other shiny objects. It was an effort to convince us that the exception was the rule. But The Last Jedi is, by every other measurement thus far, doing quite well and keeping its franchise artistically and financially healthy. That doesn’t mean you’re wrong for disliking it (I panned The Force Awakens), but that does mean that Disney and Lucasfilm have little reason not to be celebrating at the moment.

Some of comments on the IMDb:

Entertaining, but ultimately confused end! Very surprised that the critics gave this a thumbs up. It’s possibly among the worst Star Wars movies (including the prequels). It’s entertaining, for sure, but in the way David and Jerry Zucker films of the 80’s were crowd pleasers. This isn’t something you go home thinking about or affecting you when you go home, at least in a good way.

The problem as I see it is that it tried to tackle too much in one movie. Worst, it spent so much time on unimportant (and seemingly inconsequential) events and not enough time on the bigger questions that were left hanging from TFA. The story structure is a mess. The Finn/Rose subplot could’ve been totally removed, and the new characters introduced were a waste of time.

Characterizations were very inconsistent. Characters who had already grown in TFA (Finn, Poe) suddenly regressed for no reason. Major characters (Rey, Kylo, Luke) would make surprising moves without any basis or set-up, for the sake of surprise. In fact a lot of the movie can be said as favoring a "twist" happening at the expense of consistent character development. The prequel movies’ treatment of Anakin’s character development was a lot more satisfying, AND that’s a generally panned. At least the prequel movies’ story tried in earnest, TLJ did worst that just phoning it in.

As some movies have become acclaimed films over time after an initial bashing by the critics (e.g. Bladerunner), this one I believe will take the opposite direction. Here’s hoping JJ fixes everything with IX.

Total: 2 comments
Please note! In order to quote the entire comment - click “Quote” without selecting anything. To quote a part of the comment - first select it, then click “Quote”.
  1. Nicolle Steehle
    1
    4
    Nicolle SteehleJournalist
    2017-12-24, 10:24AM
    I wish the advancement of technology would fix bad writing!

    Just came back from seeing the last Star Wars Movie after the dejavu experience that was The Force Awakens. I deeply love most that is the Star Wars Universe, I, however, hate what bad writing is doing to it. I understand there is only so much depth that you can put into a 2 hour movie which also has to appeal to a young audience but some of the writing choices are just baffling to me. The look, feel and sound are pretty much spot on. As soon as the picture roles I am back in the SW Universe. Modern technology only makes it easier for us to enjoy it.

    But my lord the plot holes and bad logic used. Let me get this right for Ryan, the writer. You can't let an untrained Jedi (however powerful and force intuitive as she may be beat an experienced SIth Apprentice whose power is some of the most terrifying that we have seen (which is ridiculous in its own right) and then turn on his master without him sensing it while he was using force powers to the likes we have not seen so far on the girl who beat him in the previous movie!

    +5
  2. Chris Maccenroy
    5
    10
    Author: Chris MaccenroyJournalist
    2017-12-23, 3:49PM
    "It's time for the Jedi, and for Star Wars... to end." confounded

    The Last Jedi is one giant cinematographic anticlimax. Each sequence had a twist for the sake of a twist. Each time, the chosen twist was always the lesser of the interesting possibilities the resolution could offer. Each scene had a build up that lead to an anticlimax. Examples:

    1. Set-Up: Luke gets his blue light saber back. The biggest buildup at the end of The Force Awakens. Two years in the wait to see what Luke is going to do. Anticlimax: Luke throws the light saber away over his head in a slapstick manner.

    2. Set-up: Is Admiral Holdo a traitor? Anticlimax: Apparently she's not, she just wanted to hide her plan (of saving The Resistance) from everybody without any apparent reason, creating forced conflict.

    3. Set-up: DJ explains the war economy to Finn and Rose and shows that the weapon dealers sell weapons to both The First Order AND The Resistance. Anticlimax: Finn and Rose ignore it completely and pretend this discussion never happened.

    4. Set-up: We finally meet Snoke, the new biggest Dark Side villain of the galaxy. Who is he? Anticlimax: He's nobody, Snoke is killed off in the most anticlimactic and convenient way possible; and this in the middle of the movie!

    +11
Write a review
Information
To add a comment to this publication, you need to register or Log In.
Share a link with your friends:
With ““Star Wars” recovering? “The Last Jedi” has earned around $570m around the world” also read
MediaMost read! Not that “Star Wars”: The Last Jedi is in any danger of losing money
2 827 4 1
There’s too much momentum behind the franchise, many people who will pay to see it even when they’ve heard it’s a disappointing mess. That would be a money-losing fiasco.
MobileShopping: iPhone X, Pixel 2 or Galaxy S8 - how each phone differs from one another
2 504 1 1
iOS or Android? If you’re shopping for a new smartphone, there’s a good chance three options come to mind: Apple iPhone X, Samsung Galaxy S8, Google Pixel 2.
GadgetsBest cutting-edge products: the 10 most popular Gadgets of 2017
2 540 1
Technology companies like Microsoft, Samsung, Apple are constantly finding new ways to improve their cutting-edge products. There are several big changes in 2017.
FinanceRetail renaissance: Big Shopping Trends in 2018 - the signs are promising
2 614 4 2
2017 was the year of the retail apocalypse. Tech transformation. Retail is a people business. Predictions: pot, politics and Bitcoin. New business models will emerge.
Even more publications
New articles announcement
In the air: Recent Comments
2018-01-17, 5:53AM
Double loft beds similar the black one available in various mattress sizes made to your choice of headroom, with a choice of sloping or..To get you inspired: 12 awesome ideas where to put a bed in a tiny room
2018-01-17, 5:48AM
Great Collection of space savers! With more and more tiny houses becoming popular, ideas such as these are great examples that could be..To get you inspired: 12 awesome ideas where to put a bed in a tiny room
2018-01-16, 12:04PM
The best of interior decoration I have ever seen, awesome creativity! Cool ideas, but some of these are totally removed from possibility if..To get you inspired: 12 awesome ideas where to put a bed in a tiny room
2018-01-16, 11:07AM
As a college student wrote, this post stood out. I always have the problem of too many things in too little of a space. If this post was..To get you inspired: 12 awesome ideas where to put a bed in a tiny room
2018-01-16, 5:51AM
In-home services, delivery, and consultations will pervade the market. Consumers no longer want to leave the house to buy commodities. So,..Retail renaissance: Big Shopping Trends in 2018 - the signs are promising
2018-01-16, 5:29AM
Healthy and environment-friendly lifestyles will be a focus for many consumers. Consumers will be increasingly mindful of their purchases...Retail renaissance: Big Shopping Trends in 2018 - the signs are promising
Popular Comments
2017-11-21, 11:58AM
Who wins? Well the buyer will not. For all those who cry about your “Right to privacy” - if you are foolish enough to have one of these in..Let’s compare who wins: Google Home Mini for $50 or Amazon Echo Dot
2018-01-7, 1:22PM
Simple solutions: 1. You live off of handouts you can't vote. Let those who pay the bill decide. 2. Welfare because your a single..Welfare reform: 6 million open jobs - the challenge is to get people back to work
2017-11-21, 12:24PM
No these devices are absolutely NOT listening to every word you say, cataloging, storing, and saving. Of course NONE of these devices are..Let’s compare who wins: Google Home Mini for $50 or Amazon Echo Dot
2017-12-23, 3:49PM
"It's time for the Jedi, and for Star Wars... to end." The Last Jedi is one giant cinematographic anticlimax. Each..“Star Wars” recovering? “The Last Jedi” has earned around $570m around the world
2017-12-20, 6:07PM
This is never going to happen. Republicans are NOT going to cut, they will continue to explain that a growing economy will grow them out of..9 things about historic Tax Reform - Trump’s first big legislative win
2017-12-18, 7:10PM
The only reason to use a gift card is if you are dealing with kids and want to restrict what they can get, so for example, you get them a..13 Cool Tech Gifts you must have and don’t have to spend a fortune on them
Most viewed in the past 24 hours
Most viewed in the month
Popular news topics
5G Apple beds Bitcoin breaking news broadband business business news cryptocurrency device entertainment film finance furniture gadget gadgets Google home furniture home security ideas iPhone iPhone battery latex mattress markets mattress media mobile Motorola movie review older iPhones opinion politics reforms retail security shopping smart speaker smartphone Star Wars stocks T-Mobile tax code tax laws tax reform taxes tech tech news technology The Last Jedi U.S. Senate
» » “Star Wars” recovering? “The Last Jedi” has earned around $570m around the world